Sunday, April 21, 2013

Open Prompt #4 (Revisited)


1970 Also. Choose a work of recognized literary merit in which a specific inanimate object (e.g., a seashell, a handkerchief, a painting) is important, and write an essay in which you show how two or three of the purposes the object serves are related to one another. 

In The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien there is a special ring and whoever puts it on will be all-powerful.  The ring has incredible power and just wearing it around one’s neck is enough to turn a normal person mad with  power.  That is where one of the main character’s, a Hobbit named Frodo, comes in.  He is the only person that can refuse the urge to wear the ring and stay somewhat sane.  Throughout the story Frodo attempts to destroy the ring as its power is too great for one person.  Along the way many people try to take the ring from him so that they can harness its  incredible power. 
The inscription on the ring reads: “One ring to rule them all, one ring to find them, one ring to bring them all, and in the darkness bind them”. This really shows the purposes of the ring as intended by the author.  The ring is meant to rule others and bring power to its beholder, and it is meant to bind people and bring them together.
One of the purposes of the ring is to empower its beholder.  It has been used by many evil people in the past to rule the kingdom but somehow it ended up in the hands of small Frodo due to destiny.  Throughout the books Frodo wrestles with his conscious.  He knows he should not wear the ring but the ring constantly tempts him to try it on.  Frodo’s internal struggle is best shown by the character Smeagol.  Smeagol is basically a bipolar character that goes by both the name Smeagol and Gollum.  He has a good side (Smeagol) and a dark side (Gollum) that years of wearing the ring brought out from within him.  He is willing to kill to get the ring back when he is Gollum but knows that the ring is evil when he is Smeagol.  The wearer of the ring has the ability to teleport and all sorts of other powers.
One of the purposes of rings is to bring people together.  Rings have a circular shape that is meant to symbolize eternity.  They are often used to symbolize eternity in marriage but they can also be used to  symbolize eternal friendships and promises.   In The Lord of the Rings the ring brings unlikely people together, such as Frodo and Sam.  Before the novel they were not friends and didn’t like each other all that much but their adventures through dark places and close encounters with death created a tight, eternal bond that not even the power of the ring could break.   
The ring brings people together (“one ring to bring them all, and in the darkness bind them”) and it is a symbol of power (“one ring to rule them all”).  How do these purposes relate?  Both of these purposes are eternal as a rings shape.  The power the ring brings when it is worn is eternal and the relationships it creates are everlasting as well.  The ring brings great power, but alone one person cannot be all powerful.  The ring has the power to control all the other powerful rings in the land and utilize it.  This is very similar to the friendships it creates.  For example Frodo would not be able to do anything of great relevance alone but with his friends Sam and Gandalf he is able to do great things. 

Monday, April 15, 2013

Ceremony: Summary and Analysis

Author: This novel was written by Leslie Marmon Silko in the 1970s.  She was a mixed woman of caucasian, mexican, and Laguna Pueblo descent.  Silko was born in 1948 and lived in New Mexico. She attended the Bureau of Indian Affairs Schools, and then the University of New Mexico. 

Setting: This novel is set shortly after World War II, however flashbacks go back to the main character’s adolescence in the 1920s. The story mostly takes place in a Laguna reservation, although there are flashbacks to the Philippines and other places that Tayo has been.

Plot: The protagonist, Tayo, is suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder. He recently returned from his service in WWII and is continuing to mourn the death of his cousin Rocky who died during the war.  Tayo is looking for a way to cure himself of his PTSD and decides to undergo a ceremony in an attempt to cure himself. Tayo is living in the midst of a draught at this time as while which he believes he caused because he prayed for rain to stop when he was at war.  Tayo’s uncle Josiah died while he was at war and he had a delusion, seeing Josiah as one of the Japanese soldiers who was killed. When Tayo returned to the United States he stayed at the veteran’s hospital until he was well enough to return home. Even then, he was under the care of his Auntie, Robert, and Grandma.
Tayo’s friends Harley, Pinkie, Leroy, and Emo all fought in the war and returned to the reservation as well. They all suffer from some sort of post traumatic stress and they try to fix this problem with excessive drinking. While out, the group tries to relive their glory days and reminisce in the respect that they got while wearing their uniforms and Tayo realizes how much discrimination there is. Tayo wasn’t getting better and considered returning to the veteran’s hospital, but his grandmother called in a medicine man to help him. He performs a ceremony but the ancient remedies are not suited for his issue. It helps a little, but doesn’t make a huge impact. Tayo starts to think about his past. He remembers how close him and Rocky were the summer before they went off to the war and how Rocky called them brothers. That same summer, Josiah had a scandalous relationship with Night Swan, who was a Mexican woman. She gave him the idea to purchase Mexican cattle as well so Tayo helped him get them and watch them. There was a draught that summer so Tayo goes to a spring to do a rain ceremony and the next day it rains. Because of this, Josiah can’t make it to go see Night Swan so he asks Tayo to deliver a note for him. She seduces Tayo.
                After the medicine man sees that the ceremony hasn’t succeeded he sends Tayo to a city called Gallup where Tayo lived with his mom. He sees Betonie because he supposedly knows more about mixing cultures. Betonie says they will need to invent a new ceremony and tells him about his grandfather Descheeny and the ceremony to end the white witchery. After Betonie is done, he reminds Tayo that the ceremony is not fully complete. On his way home, Tayo is picked up by Harley, Leroy, and Helen Jean on their way to a bar. He stays for a while but then leaves and follows the signs Betonie told him about. He ends up at Ts’eh’s house where he stays the night with her and then leaves for the mountains. He finds Josiah’s cattle in a white man’s fence so he breaks into it but the cattle run away so he searches for them all night. In the morning, a mountain lion approaches him and leads him to the cattle but patrolmen catch him for trespassing but let him go so he can get the mountain lion. At this, it begins to snow so Tayo can’t find any tracks so he goes back to Ts’eh’s house and she has the cattle.
                Tayo returns home with the cattle and feels better but the draught still hasn’t ended. Robert warns Tayo that Emo has been spreading rumors about him. Emo and the police come for Tayo and Ts’eh tells him how to avoid capture. On his way, Harley and Leroy pick him up but they end up working with Emo so he runs away to an abandoned mine. He realizes that he just needs to spend the night there and the ceremony will be complete. Emo and Pinkie arrive and Tayo has to watch them torture Harley. Tayo returns home after the ceremony is complete and tells the medicine man. The draught ends and the white destruction stops. He spends one night at the medicine man’s house and the ceremony is completed.

Characters: 

Tayo: The main character. He is only half Laguna because his mother was loose with men before she died. He maintains belief in the traditional culture despite going off to fight in the war. He suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder.
Rocky: Tayo’s cousin. They were very close and fought in WWII together, but he died there. He did not believe in the traditional culture as much as Tayo.
Auntie: Tayo’s aunt and Rocky’s mother. She is the sister of Tayo’s mother. She tends to favor conforming into the white society and cares a lot about image and reputation. Married to Robert.
Josiah: Tayo’s uncle (the brother of his mother). He was a father figure for Tayo. He taught Tayo about the traditions.
Betonie: The medicine man that helps Tayo make and perform his ceremony. He is looked down upon by many because he strays from tradition to blend with the times.
Harley: Tayo’s best friend who also fought in the war with him. He is an alcoholic.
Grandma: Tayo’s grandmother who intervenes at key moments and is a wise figure.
Ku’oosh: The medicine man that takes Tayo to Betonie.
Emo: Tayo’s acquaintance since childhood who also fought in the war. He is very critical of his mixed background. Antagonist of the novel.
The Woman: Ts’eh. She is a sacred character that helps Tayo complete the ceremony at three points of time.
Voice: This novel is written as a third person narrative but it is the voice of someone who sees the thoughts of grandmother Spiderwoman. It is a relatively uninvolved narrator, but since it comes from the memory of Spiderwoman, it may not be completely reliable. The tone is uninvolved. There is a lot of symbolism involving animals and important figures in Laguna traditional belief. The author also described in great detail and provided intense imagery.

Quotes: 

“It seems like I already heard these stories before… only thing is, the names sound different.” (Grandma, 260) This quote is significant because it shows the cyclical nature of Tayo’s ceremony. The fact that Grandma has heard the story before, means that she has either heard a legend pertaining to it (such as the poems in the novel), or she has heard of another similar situation. Since she has heard of it before, and it has happened again, it implies that it will occur again and again—it is a repeating cycle.

“Sunrise.” (4) and “Sunrise, / accept this offering, / Sunrise.” (262). The repetition of “sunrise” after the ceremony has taken place, emphasizes the cyclical nature of the novel, and life itself. This reaffirms the idea that the ceremony is a repeated pattern throughout history that is only slightly carried with time.

Theme: The theme of this novel is that everything is cyclical and the importance of finding a balance of culture. This is affirmed by Betonie’s ceremony working on Tayo because it is a new ceremony that combines old ceremonies with new tradition and ideas. By blending cultures to cure the world of white destruction, the author shows that a cooperative mixture of the two cultures is necessary to have good again in the world.

Sunday, April 14, 2013

Response to Course Materials

          Since the last "Response to Course Material" we have finished Ceremony, started to read Fifth Business, and we have talked about Jung's criticism.  Ceremony was a rather difficult book for me to understand.  I still can't fully grasp what Silko's intentions were with this novel.  I can't tell if she believed in taking in a mixture of Laguna and American culture or if she believed that white people and everything associated with them is "witchery" and is seen as corruption to her.  The annotations were rather difficult as well.  I was rather confused by the frequent flashback's Tayo has and the book was filled with complex symbolism.  I think the reason annotations are harder with novels than with the plays for me is because they contain less dialogue.  I think this book will be really helpful because I needed to work on interpreting novels in depth as well.  
          I really enjoyed the lecture on Jung’s criticism. I’ve never taken a psych class, but I found these ideas to be very interesting. I haven’t really noticed them while actually reading Fifth Business though, but I haven’t gotten very far so that is probably why. This novel is really interesting, but so far I don’t really understand the author’s purpose in writing it, assuming it wasn’t just for entertainment.  The format is different than most of the books that I have read in the past and I’m not really sure why. It’s written as a first person narrative and the whole thing is supposed to be for his boss to redeem himself after what was written about him in the school paper. One thing that I like is that the situation and the narrative voice tell a lot about who the character is. You get a good feel for his character by his actions alone, but by having him as the narrator as well, expressing thoughts and viewpoints, adds a lot to it. I think we are probably reading this book because it is so different from the other pieces we have read this year. It’s good that we’re being exposed to more kinds of literature because it will help us when we try to interpret passages on the AP test and in future courses.